DarkReading Qualys Montance AlertFatigue
Presented by: Christopher Crowley
PresentationThe concept of Montance Alert Fatigue in cybersecurity refers to the prioritization of quantity over quality in alert-driven approaches, which leads to alert fatigue and ineffective security measures. This issue arises from the gap between functionality and security, where organizations often prioritize functionality over security, creating vulnerabilities that threat actors can exploit. To address this, cybersecurity teams must optimize business alignment, develop better detection engineering, and adopt hunting as a paradigm, among other strategies, to fill the gap and prioritize security.
Full Transcript / Content
--- Page 1 ---
Christopher Crowley
- Consultant: Montance®
- SOC-Class.com:
Design, Build, Operate and
Mature your SOC.
- SOC-Survey.com: 2017-2021
- SANS Senior Instructor
- Sectors: Defense, Education,
Energy, Government, Financial,
Software Dev., Telecom…
Montance® LLC
1
--- Page 2 ---
Current State
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 2Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 3 ---
(How) Is Security Still a Problem?
- We’ve been alert-driven for two decades
- (Prior to that, we didn’t even have alerts to chase)
Montance® LLC
3
Source: Verizon 2021 Data Breach Investigations Report
--- Page 4 ---
No Stagnation in the Industry
- Prevailing sentiment is there’s little progress being
made or things are worse than ever
- I disagree, will explain in a couple slides
- Losses are worse than ever
- Yet, the cybersecurity industry is booming
- NYT 2021-07-26: Cyber investment $12B in 2021 so far,
up 20% from 2020’s total for entire year
- Cyber staff, consistently cited as a growth field
- Example: Growing a Stronger Federal Cyber Workforce,
Cyberspace Solarium Commission (2020-09-04)
Montance® LLC
4
--- Page 5 ---
What’s the Fundamental Reason?
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 5Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 6 ---
It’s Simple: Function Before Security
- Despite substantial improvements in
- Operating system and app controls,
- System architecture,
- Encryption deployments for communication
- Multi-factor authentication,
- Cybersecurity technology, and
- Patching;
- IT operations continues to change at a pace that
security cannot keep up with.
Montance® LLC
6
--- Page 7 ---
Systems Pushed to Their Limits
- The information systems we deploy are general
purpose operating systems, running general purpose
processors.
- The information systems we deploy have a lifespan
on the order of 5 years, then are obsolete.
- If you don’t regularly articulate this reality, start.
- These brains often power durable goods with
substantially longer expected lifespans without plans
for updating and retrofitting new brains.
Montance® LLC
7
--- Page 8 ---
Effectively Profiting From the Gap
- With functionality prioritized over security, and
information systems engineered to be capable of
running lots of things and often retained well
beyond the intended lifespan,
- Cybersecurity is tasked with filling the Gap
- Threat actors look for profit opportunities, and
have been extremely successful. This is a “tax”
on the global information ecosystem.
Montance® LLC
8
--- Page 9 ---
Our Task is to Minimize Impact
from this Weakness
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 9Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 10 ---
Cybersecurity Fills the Gap
- Our cyber mission is to deal with the
shortcomings of the systems as deployed
- Keep them running optimally and protect the
data within them from disclosure and alteration
- This entails ongoing:
- posture reconciliation, maybe even improvement
- noticing when something is going awry, and
responding to minimize the damage
- Some ways to do this
Montance® LLC
10
--- Page 11 ---
Do All of The Following
- Some specific items follow
- They’re not mutually exclusive, employ any and
all of these techniques
- Each represents a facet of our resilience and
adaptively converting the burden of too much
information into something useful
Montance® LLC
11
--- Page 12 ---
Better Business Alignment
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 12Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 13 ---
Optimize What Is Ignored
- Constantly evangelize your need-to-know to uncover
business relevance. It takes confidence to focus only on
some systems without attempting to cover all possible
defensive opportunities. It takes discipline to be a SOC
who doesn’t help everyone who requests assistance.
- Start: MITRE ATT&CK defensive coverage based on
sector-focused threat information indicates where your
coverage is best spend
- Maturing: Track what you’ve encountered and cases of
suffered impacts to augment defenses
- Optimized: Business-risk coordinated use case
development for detection and response capability
Montance® LLC
13
--- Page 14 ---
Better Metrics
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 14Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 15 ---
Optimize Collected Data and Analysis
- Most metrics used and reported are ineffective and
driving performance
- Mean time to X is a standard metric, telling people
to go faster, frequently without a corresponding
quality measure
- Quantify impact. It’s a harder metric to calculate,
and takes business alignment to derive. But it shows
where we deploy security well and where we don’t
(because there was a big impact).
Montance® LLC
15
--- Page 16 ---
Better Detection Engineering
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 16Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 17 ---
Detection Engineering
- Using data available to make better decisions about
deploying cybersecurity resources
- Multiple variations on the same technique
- Detection opportunities by more rigorous IT deployments
and operational practices
- Threat Intelligence to determine methods adversaries
deploy
- Better visibility through instrumentation of operating
systems and applications
- Differentiation between normal and unauthorized using
behaviorally cued data elements
- could be trained through observation and historical tracking
or machine learning techniques or speculated
Montance® LLC
17
--- Page 18 ---
Embrace Hunting as a Paradigm
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 18Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 19 ---
Hunting as a Paradigm
“Therefore I have heard of military operations that
were clumsy but swift, but I have never seen one that
was skillful and lasted a long time.”
– The Art of War, Sun Tzu
- Not always enough time to engineer good detections
- Develop a framework for hunts, and use that rigor to
cultivate creativity and relentless pursuit in your
cybersecurity staff.
- We’re compromised, but we can’t yet see it
Montance® LLC
19
--- Page 20 ---
Good Hunting Drives Good Engineering
- Hunting is “clumsy but swift” yet we want swiftness
to inform where the engineering effort is actually
worth deploying a lot of effort
- One hunting outcome is ideas for use cases
- Hunts show gaps and oversights, posture
improvement recommendations and revisions are
another outcome of hunts
- Leverage vendor partners and community efforts as
the basis of your engineered detections, then
customize as appropriate for your environment,
hunting helps develop these customizations
Montance® LLC
20
--- Page 21 ---
Better Tools for Analysts
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 21Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 22 ---
The Tools Are Very Good
- Automation as standard practice for your team
- Ten years ago, security automation meant custom
programming; not anymore
- But, I consistently hear about the
“orchestration/automation project” or
implementation: your adaptive state going forward
- Behavioral based has shortcomings but is good
- List the good, not the bad has been embraced
(digital signature restriction: iOS, for example)
Montance® LLC
22
--- Page 23 ---
More Telemetry than Ever Before
- Data instrumentation, ingestion, storage,
correlation, and enrichment are abundant
- Our tools are positioned to show the analyst
what the analyst needs to know
- Performance can be good if appropriate
optimizations are applied and curated over time
- Powerful and fast tools are a reality
- Suites of integrated tools (and customizable
integration) are readily available
Montance® LLC
23
--- Page 24 ---
Better Analysts
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 24Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 25 ---
Our People are Excellent
- Cultivate intelligence and analysis
- Good work practices: mental health,
attentiveness, awareness, skepticism, humility,
communication
- Mentor staff and cultivate team training and
information sharing through threat intel and
internal / external training portfolio
Montance® LLC
25
--- Page 26 ---
Better Analysis
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 26Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 27 ---
What’s The SOC’s Methodology?
- Maintain an analytical methodology for your
SOC team (ACH, for example)
- Some SOCs say ACH or “scientific method”
because it sounds good, and is not actually
consistently implemented or followed
- Showing one’s work is part of the responsibility
of being an analyst. The methodology supports
this explanation / rationale.
Montance® LLC
27
--- Page 28 ---
Embrace Deception
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 28Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 29 ---
Make Hacking Your Network Hard!
- That’s your network! Make it a scary place for
attackers to operate within
“You go out with your master skeleton key and
unlock the door and you're in. It's not that. Take
these big, corporate networks, these large
networks, any large network -- I will tell you that
persistence and focus will get you in, will achieve
that exploitation, without the zero-days.”
- Rob Joyce, Chief (at time of Quote) NSA TAO
Montance® LLC
29
--- Page 30 ---
Easier to Detect
- We complain about being overwhelmed because of the
difficulty differentiating normal from unauthorized.
- Leaving assets around that adversaries might feasibly use, and
tracking that use.
- Read access on files, rows in databases, file shares in DMZs
that shouldn’t be mounted, plain text password file with
accounts and passwords.
- Observation networks for containment of suspected systems
that present potential targets representing a reasonable mirror
of your actual network
- Email addresses on your website that are spam traps
- Phishing lures that supposedly provide “access” to VIPs
- “Live off the land” traps listed: LOLBALS-Project
Montance® LLC
30
--- Page 31 ---
Embrace the Cloud
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 31Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 32 ---
Cloud
- Your network is actually someone else’s network
that you’re just a guest in.
- If you’re not already architecting this, you’re late
- Extract the most important elements and develop
your use cases (aforementioned business alignment)
- The appropriate place to engage these issues is with
your constituents prior to deployment, at the cloud
selection and contracting phase. If you’re not
present in those meetings, you’ll stay overloaded.
Montance® LLC
32
--- Page 33 ---
Cloud
- This supposed problem is an opportunity for
improvement in your security integration into the IT
operational cycle. You’re relived of at least 30% of
your vulnerability management issues.
- The data to monitor is less than your internally
managed systems, focus on that available data.
- Architect solutions with security integrations and
offer that to IT. I have seen many offerings from 3rd
parties which address cloud security architecture.
Montance® LLC
33
--- Page 34 ---
Fight for What is Right
SOC-Class.com || Montance® LLC 34Copyright 2021 Montance® LLC - All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Reversed?
--- Page 35 ---
Focus on Mission for Performance
- It’s an unfair and unjust world
- While our organizations want an autonomous
and automated SOC, for now it comes down to
the people who run it to fill the gaps.
- When the SOC staff have a mobilized sense of
mission, they’ll deal with technology
shortcomings, effective adversaries, and a lack of
support, yet still rise to the occasion every time.
Montance® LLC
35
Related Q&A
- Q: What is the primary problem addressed in this report?A: Alert Fatigue in Security Operations Centers.
- Q: How does Qualys propose to reduce alert fatigue?A: By providing better context and prioritization of vulnerabilities and threats.
- Q: What is 'AssetView'?A: A Qualys service that provides a unified view of IT assets to help prioritize risks.