Sans Webcast Designing And Building A SOC In House Vs Out Sourcing
Document
The core technical concepts discussed in the segment "Designing And Building A SOC In House Vs Out Sourcing" in MGT517 include the six components of a Security Operations Center (SOC): Command Center, Network Security Monitoring (NSM), Threat Intelligence, Incident Response, Forensics, and Self-Assessment. The segment also explores the hiring and mentoring of SOC staff, as well as the pros and cons of outsourcing specific SOC components or entire teams, including factors such as cost, capability, scalability, flexibility, and industry familiarity.
Full Transcript / Content
--- Page 1 ---
MGT517
SOC Roles: In-house
versus Outsourcing
Managing Security Operations: Detection, Response, and Intelligence
© 2016 Christopher Crowley | All Rights Reserved | Version B01_01
--- Page 2 ---
2MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Requirements for SOC Components
- Security Operations Centers are the organization’s
central capability for efficient, effective monitoring
and response
- The Org may:
Have legal requirements to have a SOC
Decided to consolidate security to achieve optimization
Not be able to afford SOC, but sees the value
2
--- Page 3 ---
3MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Functional Components of SOC Components
- We start by defining the functional capabilities a SOC is
expected to perform
- Each of these areas may be internal, partially outsourced
(to accomplish 24x7 coverage, for example), or
completely outsourced
- Let’s briefly discuss each of the areas for context. This is
the functional framework in MGT517
- If you want to hear more details, see previous webcast:
https://bit.ly/mgt517-soc-fundamental
--- Page 4 ---
4MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Functional Components of SOC Components
- Command Center
Maintains Situational Awareness and directs action
Interfaces with constituents and public
- Network Security Monitoring
Monitors all internal assets
- Threat Intelligence
Discovers adversary characteristics and guides detection and
response with this information
--- Page 5 ---
5MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Functional Components of SOC Components
- Incident Response
Reactively addresses issues
- Forensics
In depth study of information assets
- Self-Assessment
Internal asset assessment: configurations, vulnerabilities,
pen testing, exercises
Compels the organization to “harden the target”
--- Page 6 ---
6MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Hiring Staff Staffing
- Strong technical interview process
- Hire from within company into Junior positions
Gives help desk and other staff a growth objective
- Hire life-long learners
- Hire people with a reason to stay with the company
- Fight for flexible work from home positions for high
demand roles, be ready with good comm tools
In-house Hiring Guidance
--- Page 7 ---
7MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Mentoring Staff Staffing
- Seek funding for external training
- Cultivate internal training development
(One example on next slide)
- Practice tasks – require staff to spend time practicing
Scripts, Internal tools – 2 hours per week, required
Encourage external presentation by paying for travel to
conferences if staff are approved for presentations
Training, Exercise, and Practice
--- Page 8 ---
8MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Staff Development Staffing
- SOC staff rotates on presenting current technique,
issue or problem
- This can be an unresolved problem, seeking input
and assistance from all SOC areas
- Opportunity to share methodology, thought
processes, and tools
- Should be a formal presentation (slides, Q+A)
Monthly Staff Presentations
--- Page 9 ---
9MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Size Estimation
- Most businesses approach outsourcing specialties as
a sound business decision
- There are arguments for and against
- Explore these arguments on next couple of slides
--- Page 10 ---
10MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Staffing
- Cost
- Access specialists’ knowledge you can’t afford to hire
- 24x7 coverage
- Experience of other environments and customers
- Eliminate task of hiring (transferred to partner)
- Objective 3rd party to investigate internal threats
Arguments for Outsourcing
--- Page 11 ---
11MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Staffing
- Maintain control
- Customization and tailoring
- Growth and development of staff and capability
- Trusted / vetted staff accessing your data
- Environment baseline and organizational insight
- Ownership of defense and reduction of risk
Arguments for In-house
--- Page 12 ---
12MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Size Estimation
- For each of the functional components identified
earlier, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of
outsourcing each functional area
--- Page 13 ---
13MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
SOC / Command Center Outsourcing
- Your command and control capability emanates
from the SOC. Transferring this control to another
party isn’t advised, but frequently happens in an
insourced arrangement.
- Organizations outsource components of public
relations
- Call in function in help desk as a tier 1 call service
with escalation to C2
--- Page 14 ---
14MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Network Security Monitoring (NSM) Outsourcing
- Best to retain NSM internally
- Frequently the 24x7x365 requirements and rare skillset
drives business to outsource
- Downside to outsourced NSM is lack of effective contextual
understanding of business, minimal opportunities for
correlation unless all data is sent to MSSP
- Best use of outsourcing is augmenting existing competencies
- Outsourcing helps assure best practices and efficiencies
--- Page 15 ---
15MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Threat Intelligence Outsourcing
- With mature internal NSM, you won’t outsource threat intel
Still will likely buy IP lists, for example: website categories lists for proxy
- If you don’t have good internal NSM, you probably will
outsource your threat intel
- Outsourced threat intel has a short useful lifespan
…attacks observed by RiskAnalytics during 2014, 75% of attacks
spread from Victim 0 to Victim 1 within one day (24 hours). Over
40% hit the second organization in less than an hour.
Source: 2015 Verizon DBIR
--- Page 16 ---
16MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Incident Response Outsourcing
- IR function is a cornerstone activity
- Actually a reasonable SOC function to outsource
- Downsides: less customized, less agile response
- Upsides of outsourcing are leveraging external competencies
developed in other areas, and possibly only paying for what
you use – an incentive for effective security architecture; but
a double edge sword of not calling for help when you need it
--- Page 17 ---
17MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Forensics Outsourcing
- Host; Network; Reverse Engineering; eDiscovery
- All are commonly outsourced because organizations
can’t afford the expertise
- Large well funded SOCs have difficulty hiring /
retaining strong forensic staff
- Downsides include even higher cost than internal
staff, outsourced company isn’t fast enough, low
value for expense
--- Page 18 ---
18MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Self-Assessment Outsourcing
- Usually retained internal to organization
- Partial outsourcing is common, such as monitoring
deviation of hosts and firewalls from a known good state
- Could easily be outsourced, but the out-sourced party
would have no incentive to help you improve your
configuration. They’d be working themselves out of a job
Configuration Monitoring
--- Page 19 ---
19MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Self-Assessment Outsourcing
- Vulnerability Assessment is frequently outsourced
- Many third parties will happily scan your networks
for you
- Reasonable task to define specific conditions,
specific deliverables, and transfer responsibility
- Many options to choose from provide this service
Vulnerability Assessment
--- Page 20 ---
20MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Self-Assessment Outsourcing
- Penetration Testing is almost always out-sourced
- Large number of companies to perform pen tests
- Most are glorified vulnerability scans
- What’s the difference? Creativity and the relentless
drive to compromise systems. Also, the authority to
exploit, versus having to stop before exploitation.
Penetration Testing
--- Page 21 ---
21MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Self-Assessment Outsourcing
- Exercises are best in-sourced, but there’s a unique
thing that happens with exercises that are
outsourced: Management pays attention to the
results
- Outsourced design and performance of exercises
with internal direction and coordination is the most
common scenario
Exercises
--- Page 22 ---
22MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Staffing
- Your internal processes well defined
- Effective interfaces
Inputs
Artifacts
- SLAs
Escalation requirements
Speed
Managing Outsourced Relationships
--- Page 23 ---
23MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Outsourcing Staffing
- Cost
- Capability
- Scalability
- Flexibility
- Industry familiarity
- Extractability (are you locked in?)
Outsource Partner Selection Criteria
--- Page 24 ---
24MGT517 | Managing Security Operations
Upcoming
Beta #2
Washington, DC
Nov. 28
–
Dec 2
SANS 2017
Orlando, FL
April 9
–
13
Threat Summit
New
Orleans,LA
April 20
-
24
Related Q&A
- Q: What is the 'Hybrid SOC' model advocated in the webcast?A: Retaining core incident response and threat hunting expertise in-house while outsourcing 24/7 monitoring and log collection to an MSSP.
- Q: What is the primary hidden cost of an 'In-house Only' SOC?A: The high cost of recruiting, training, and retaining skilled staff, and the overhead of managing 24/7 shifts.
- Q: What is the major downside of 'Fully Outsourced' security?A: The lack of business context and the potential for a 'black box' service where the organization loses visibility into its own data.