Technology Taxonomy Crowley Pescatore
Presented by: Christopher Crowley
PresentationThe Technology Taxonomy Crowley Pescatore framework is organized into four primary categories: Identify, Protect, Detect, and Respond, which are based on the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF). Additionally, the framework includes a second pass, "Crowley Categories," which further breaks down these categories into sub-areas such as Visibility, Communication, Operations, Detection and Prevention, Storage, Deception, and Analysis, providing a more detailed and comprehensive taxonomy for cybersecurity technology selection and integration.
Full Transcript / Content
--- Page 1 ---
Technology Taxonomy
SOC-Class.com
--- Page 2 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 2
Who Am I?
I Know Some Stuff, and I Do Some Things
--- Page 3 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 3
Enterprise Technology Selection Technology Intro
- There’s no such thing as “SOC software”
- You have to make many tools work together,
the tools weren’t necessarily designed to play
nicely with others
- No authoritative reference for technology
taxonomy
- It’s a marketing-vendor and analyst-research-
industry driven treadmill
--- Page 4 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 4
Technology Taxonomy
--- Page 5 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 5
Pass 1 – NIST CSF
--- Page 6 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 6
NIST CSF Reference
Identify Protect Detect Respond Recover
Cyber Security Framework
--- Page 7 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 7
NIST CSF – SOC Survey Mapping One List – SOC Survey
- Asset discovery and inventory
- Log management
- Risk analysis and assessment SIEM (security
information and event manager)
Identify
--- Page 8 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 8
NIST CSF – SOC Survey Mapping One List – SOC Survey
- Access protection and
control/VPN
- Application whitelisting
- Deception technologies such as
honeypotting
- Data loss prevention
- Egress filtering
- Ingress filtering
Protect
- Malware detonation device (inline
malware destruction)
- Malware protection system (MPS)
- Network Access Control (NAC)
- Next-generation firewall (NGF)
- SSL/TLS traffic inspection
- Web application firewall (WAF)
- Web proxy
--- Page 9 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 9
NIST CSF – SOC Survey Mapping One List – SOC Survey
- Application log monitoring
- Continuous monitoring and
assessment
- Behavioral analysis and detection
- Endpoint monitoring and logging
- DNS log monitoring
- Customized or tailored SIEM use-case
monitoring
- AI or machine learning
- eDiscovery (support legal requests for
specific information collection)
- External threat intelligence (for online
precursors)
Detect
- Frequency analysis for network connections
- Full packet capture
- Netflow analysis
- Network intrusion detection system
(IDS)/Intrusion prevention system (IPS)
- Network traffic monitoring
- Packet analysis (other than full PCAP)
- Threat hunting
- Threat intelligence (open source, vendor
provided)
- User behavior and entity monitoring
--- Page 10 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 10
NIST CSF – SOC Survey Mapping One List – SOC Survey
- Endpoint or host-based detection and response (EDR)
- DoS and DDoS protection
- Deception technologies
Respond
--- Page 11 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 11
NIST CSF – SOC Survey Mapping One List – SOC Survey
- Ransomware prevention
- Vulnerability remediation
Recover
--- Page 12 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 12
Pass 2 – Crowley Categories
--- Page 13 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 13
SOC System Secure Architecture
Visibility
(External
Awareness)
Comm-
unication Ops Detection & Prevention Storage Deception Analysis
SOC Systems - Overall
--- Page 14 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 14
SOC System Secure Architecture
Visibility
(External Awareness)
Threat Intel
Portals
Operational
Status
information
News
information Weather Internet Weather
Visibility – External Awareness
--- Page 15 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 15
SOC System Secure Architecture
Communication
Phone Encryption for Communication Websites
Portals: Status,
Metrics,
Incident,
Ticketing
SOC Systems
--- Page 16 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 16
SOC System Secure Architecture
Operations
Automation &
Orchestration Ticketing
Dev,QA,Stage of
Production/Operational
tools
SOC Systems - Overall
--- Page 17 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 17
SOC System Secure Architecture
Detection & Prevention
Endpoint: EDR, App
whitelisting, DLP,
Behavioral Analytics, e-
Discovery, logs,
containment / response
tools
Network: NIDS, PCAP,
taps, logs, containment /
response tools,
detonation devices
Infrastructure: Switch,
Firewall configuration,
logs, containment /
response tools, WiFi
Extrastructure: Cloud,
Social analysis (not threat
intel, but compromise
and data), Cellular, ISP
dependency, partner
capability, tertiary DNS,
CDN, connectors / APIs,
logs, containment /
response tools
Correlation: SIEM, LCE,
etc.
SOC Systems
--- Page 18 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 18
SOC System Secure Architecture
Storage
Data Aggregation: Data lakes,
Federation,
Separation/Compartmentalization
Retention: disks, discovery
requirements, Physical Controls: backups, safes, Destruction
SOC Systems
--- Page 19 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 19
SOC System Secure Architecture
Deception
Internet
connectivity Models
Honeytokens:
files, folders,
accounts,
Honeypots:
endpoints,
servers,
networks
SOC Systems
--- Page 20 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 20
SOC System Secure Architecture
Analysis
Modeling and
Testing
Equipment
Baseline
systems
Correlation,
Mapping
Forensics:
Endpoint,
Network,
Scanners
Code
manipulation:
disassembler,
debugger
Simulators
SOC Systems
--- Page 21 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 21
Portfolio Options Technology Selection
Twitter, news sites, Threat connect, OTX, Maltego CE, MRTG,
RRD tool, MITRE ATT&CK
Visibility
(External Awareness)
GPG, Skype, Slack, Linux servers Communication
The Hive, RTIROps
SIFT, GRR, Winpmem/Volatility, OSSEC, syslog,
SecurityOnion, ELK, Wireshark, Kismet, Cuckoo
Detection &
Prevention
MySQL, Postgresql, syslog, ELKStorage
Tor, public access, Remnux, ADHD, Canary tokens, KippoDeception
Virtualbox, GDB, Immunity, Metasploit, radare2, STIGs,
Timesketch, Maltego CE, Yara, SIFT, Burp, Arachni, JaD-XAnalysis
Typical Open Source
--- Page 22 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 22
Portfolio Options Technology Selection
Threat Connect, OTX, Maltego, What’s Up, MITRE ATT&CKVisibility (External Awareness)
Vonage Cloud, Exchange PKI, Microsoft Teams, AWS EC2, Communication
CyberCPR, Jira+Confluence, Demisto, ZenDeskOps
SafeBack, FTK, F-response, Tripwire, Windows Defender, AppLocker, Bitlocker,
Fortinet, NetWitness, LogRhythm, ProofPoint, Tripwire, AirDefense, AlienVaultDetection & Prevention
AWS EC2, Azure, Dropbox, Shredding / IronMountainStorage
Cable / DSL connection, VMWare Workstation, Honeybot, Authentic8Deception
VMWare Workstation, CobaltStrike, Trackwise Change Management, Tripwire,
PowerShell DSC, CaseFile, Maltego, FRED workstation, Burp Professional,
Hopper, JEB
Analysis
Typical Moderate
--- Page 23 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 23
Portfolio Options Technology Selection
RecordedFuture, Crowdstrike, CarbonBlack, Tivoli, Cisco NetFlow, iSIGHTVisibility (External Awareness)
Avaya, Silent Circle, iOS phones, PKI signed user certs Communication
Service Now, Phantom(Splunk), Remedy Ops
Tableau, Fireeye HX, CarbonBlack Protect, Encase eDiscovery, Cylance Protect, McAfee FDE, Cellebrite
UFED, Cisco FirePOWER, Splunk (logging), Solera, Arbor Network, Cisco wIPS, Palo Alto, Fireeye AX,
McAfee Skyhigh, Splunk Enterprise Security
Detection & Prevention
Tenable LCE, data lake from SIEM, SAN LUNs, Safe with logging and per user access control,
Commercial degausser Storage
Authentic8, VMWare vSphere, redundant non-attributable network, Javelin Networks, Cymmetria
MazeRunner, Joe SandboxDeception
VMWare Workstation, CobaltStrike, CaseFile, Maltego, FRED workstation, Burp Professional, IDA Pro,
CoreImpact, Rapid7 Nexpose, ServiceNow (change control), McAfee ePolicy Auditor, Chef/Puppet,
Crowstrike Falcon X, Cisco AMP, Cellebrite UFED 4PC, Encase Enterprise, Tenable SC
Analysis
Typical Enterprise
--- Page 24 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 24
Additional Technology Thoughts
--- Page 25 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 25
Secure SOC Architecture Secure Architecture
- The SOC contains all information for defense of your organization
- It should be considered a critical infrastructure component
- SOC information systems receive substantial protection of:
- Integrity
- Availability
- Confidentiality
- Failure represents a loss of control, or perception that the
information systems are operating normally when they are not
SOC is the Defense
--- Page 26 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 26
SOC System Administration Secure Architecture
- Considerations in systems administration for the SOC resources
- Separation of duties between operations and SOC activities
- Redundant system administration staff in both SOC and IT Operations is costly
- Available skillset to manage systems, IT Ops SysAdmins might not be capable
of administrating specialized SOC systems
- Decision
- ROM 1 and 10 will transfer basic SysAdmin duties to IT Ops, probably have one
or two people with shared responsibility for SOC system
- ROM 100 and 1,000 will have dedicated internal System Admins, with a
subfunction in Command Center or NSM for this work
SOC Systems – who manages them?
--- Page 27 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 27
Technology Integration The Program
- In addition to selecting specific technologies you
must assure that your tools interface with one
another and your ticket and tracking systems
- Having a well-designed process makes this easier
- We’ll discuss data flow tomorrow in operation. A
defined operational plan enables specifying
electronic information exchange requirements at
Request for Proposal (RFP) from vendors
Interoperability
--- Page 28 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 28
Technology Integration The Program
- Scripting
- Challenge of long term maintenance, adequate skillset
- Professional Services
- Expensive, can be difficult to schedule in time
- Only select compatible products
- Lock-in, missed opportunities
- Automation / Orchestration Tool
- Current practice (and the latest buzzy marketing word)
What is the Data Glue?
--- Page 29 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 29
SOC Components Technology Intro
- Location – decide on centralized or distributed
- Perhaps a follow the sun model for Global organizations
- Insulation of SOC staff
- SOC staff generally are not available to handle direct
requests and should be physically isolated
- Have a help desk function (either part of the SOC, or
your actual help desk) between technical staff and
customers
--- Page 30 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 30
Selection Factors Technology Intro
- You may be fortunate enough to have funding
to get all of these things initially
- Important factors
- Information transfer between systems
- Vendor support / relationship
- Configurability and customization
- Adequate volume support, scalability and growth
path
--- Page 31 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 31
Detailed Selection Criteria Technology Intro
- Best practices and patterns – are they provided? Or is it DIY?
- Configuration – Ease of configuration
- Convention – What is the standard use?
- Horizontal scaling – Scalability within SOC framework
- Testing – Can you test it? How?
- Scaffolding – Configuration helpers, or manual coding
required?
Part One
--- Page 32 ---
Copyright Christopher Crowley
Security Operations 32
Detailed Selection Criteria Technology Intro
- Monitoring – How will you track the performance and
issues?
- Track record – Support offering, other customers, company
survivable?
- Integration – Data portability, data integration, connectors
available?
- Modularity –Data transfer capabilities based on objects or
raw data?
Part Two